Home / Parenting & Family

Solved

Childcare centre or let grandparents look after baby? Torn.

My mum offered to look after our 1 year old so we save on infant care fees, but I worry about her energy and the lack of structured learning. Childcare is pricey but socialises them. How did you all decide?
Anonymous asker ·Asked on 21 days ago ·442 views ·3 answers

3 contributors answered

Best Answer
Techie Jun Hao Beginner First-hand experience Software engineer at a local startup, can talk salary bands, layoffs and whether bootcamp worth it or not.
We did a hybrid and it was the best of both, so consider that before choosing one extreme. Grandparents give love, one-on-one attention and continuity that no centre matches at that age, and the cost saving is huge, but you're right that energy and structured stimulation are real concerns, chasing a toddler all day is exhausting for someone in their 60s. What worked for us: grandma looked after our girl 3 days, and we put her in childcare 2 days for socialisation and structured play. Grandma got rest days, our kid got peer interaction, and we still saved a lot versus full childcare. Also remember the government infant/childcare subsidies (basic plus additional based on income) make centres more affordable than the sticker price, check what you'd actually pay after subsidy before assuming it's unaffordable. Whatever you choose, at 1 year old the biggest developmental need is responsive, loving care, and grandma wins on that hands down. Socialisation matters more from 2 to 3 onwards, so you have time. Don't discount grandma's option out of "structured learning" guilt.
HR Sis Michelle Beginner First-hand experience 15 years in HR, seen enough resignation drama and lowball offers to know what is fair pay in SG.
Be honest about your mum's energy, a toddler is relentless. My mum burned out after 6 months and felt guilty admitting it. If she does it, get a part-time helper or do a few days of childcare to lighten her load. Don't let filial guilt run her into the ground.
Anonymous contributor Beginner First-hand experience
Grandparents for the first two years, then childcare, worked great for us. At one year old the structured learning thing is overrated honestly, they mostly need love, safety and sleep. But do set clear boundaries early on food, screen time and discipline or you'll clash later. Aligned expectations save relationships.

Answer this

or Log in Answer with your account and build reputation.

Related questions

1
Parenting & Family 5 answers Solved

Infant care centre vs grandparents vs helper for a newborn in SG, how did you decide and any regrets?

My maternity leave is ending and my wife and I are torn between putting our baby in infant…

114 views
5
Parenting & Family 3 answers Solved

Infant care centre or leave baby with grandparents? Torn about the decision

Maternity leave is ending and we can't decide, put our baby in an infant care centre or ha…

819 views
3
Parenting & Family 3 answers Bounty 5 points

Infant care centre vs grandparents for childcare, what did you choose?

Both of us work full-time, maternity leave ending soon. Infant care has long waitlists and…

157 views
0
Parenting & Family 2 answers Bounty 5 points

Infant care vs grandparents for childcare, what did you choose?

Both my wife and I work full-time and our maternity and paternity leave is ending soon. We…

4 views
23
Parenting & Family 4 answers Solved

Is a confinement nanny worth 4k for the first month?

First baby due soon and my mum keeps pushing for a confinement nanny at around 4k for 28 d…

326 views
5
Parenting & Family 4 answers Bounty 5 points

What's it like being a stay-home dad in Singapore?

My wife earns more and we're considering I stay home to look after our newborn. In SG this…

776 views