With COE so high, is owning a car even worth it for a young family?

Question

We have a baby and a toddler and lugging them around on public transport plus Grab is getting tiring. But COE is insane now. Does owning a car make financial sense for a family or should we just keep Grab-ing?

Regular Sergeant Faiz · Accepted Answer

Ran the numbers hard before buying with two young kids. Truth: owning a car in SG is almost never the cheaper option versus Grab and public transport, the COE, depreciation, insurance, road tax, parking and petrol easily hit 1.8k to 2.5k a month all-in for a modest car. If you Grab less than say 1.5k a month, ownership loses on pure cost. BUT with a baby and toddler, you're not really paying for transport, you're paying for convenience, car seats already installed, going out without begging for a Grab in the rain with a screaming kid, boot for the stroller and groceries. That has real value for a young family that no spreadsheet captures. My advice: if you can comfortably afford it without straining your savings and CPF for the flat, a car in these years is a quality-of-life buy, not an investment. Consider a used car with a few years of COE left to soften the hit.

Uncle Chua Retiree · Answer

We stayed car-lite: no car, but we splurge on Grab guilt-free with the money we save. Works out way cheaper than ownership and no COE heartache. The car-seat Grab options and family MRT trips cover us. Only tough during the newborn phase honestly.

SMU Grad Xinyi · Answer

Look at a used car or even car-sharing (BlueSG, GetGo) before committing to COE. We use car-sharing for weekend errands and Grab on weekdays. Total cost is a fraction of ownership and we skip parking and maintenance entirely.

Dog Dad Terrence · Answer

Bought a car when my second was born and don't regret it despite the cost, but I'll be honest it delayed our other financial goals. Just go in clear-eyed that it's a lifestyle expense during the young-kids years, not something that saves money. Sell when they're older if you want.

With COE so high, is owning a car even worth it for a young family?

4 contributors answered

Answer this

Related questions

With COE crossing 100k, is owning a car in Singapore still worth it, or is Grab and MRT the smarter move?

How do you decide whether to buy a car in Singapore now or keep waiting for COE to drop?

Why do Singaporeans still buy cars when the COE is insane? Is owning one ever worth it?

COE hit 100k again, is it worth buying a car in Singapore or just Grab everything?

COE is insanely high now. Buy a car anyway or wait it out?

Is buying a car in Singapore with COE so high even worth it?